GoodBuy Gear review

Updated September 30, 2026 · NurseryCue Editorial Team · Facts checked September 30, 2026

We earn a commission when you sign up through links on this site. Partner status can affect where a brand appears in our rankings.

Our verdict

GoodBuy Gear suits US parents after a birth who want new and second-hand gear in the same place. It stocks 60 brands, offers a price match and a 14 day money-back period, though delivery only reaches US and free delivery needs $100.

Key facts

Best for
US parents hunting second-hand baby gear with a price match and a short returns window.
Brands stocked
60 (Source, checked September 30, 2026)
Free delivery threshold
$100 (Source, checked September 30, 2026)
Shipping fee
$14.99 (Source, checked September 30, 2026)
Money-back period
14 days (Source, checked September 30, 2026)
Price match
Yes (Source, checked September 30, 2026)
Second-hand
Yes (Source, checked September 30, 2026)
Markets
US (Source, checked September 30, 2026)
Legal entity
Good Buy Gear, Inc. (Source, checked September 30, 2026)
Headquarters
United States (Source, checked September 30, 2026)
Support channels
Email, Chat, Help-centre (Source, checked September 30, 2026)
Official website
goodbuygear.com

Apps and profiles

Elsewhere
LinkedInX

Pros and cons

Pros

  • Price match is offered, so a cheaper listing elsewhere does not have to be the last word.
  • Second-hand gear is sold, which widens choice for parents working to a budget.
  • A 14 day money-back period sits mid-field among the stores compared.
  • Stocks 60 brands, matching the category median of 60.
  • Support runs through email, chat and help centre, which covers chat and a help centre.

Cons

  • Free delivery needs an order of $100, higher than buybuy BABY at $49.99, Albee Baby at $99 and Mothercare at SGD 60.
  • Shipping costs $14.99 on smaller orders, which ranks 21 of 23 on shipping fee.
  • Delivery only runs in the United States, so anyone shopping outside that market buys without store delivery.
  • Support runs on email, chat and help centre only, with no phone line listed.

Ready to try GoodBuy Gear?

Scored 8.7 / 10 by NurseryCue.

Visit

Who it suits

  • Parents in the US clearing out or buying second-hand strollers, carriers and car seats.
  • Shoppers who want a price match and a 14 day return window in one store.
  • Families willing to top up an order past $100 to drop the $14.99 shipping charge.

Who should look elsewhere

  • Anyone outside US, since delivery does not extend further.
  • Buybuy BABY shoppers who would rather clear free delivery at $49.99 than $100.
  • Parents who want a phone line, since support runs on email, chat and help centre only.

Core features

GoodBuy Gear is a multi-brand store rather than a single-label shop, stocking 60 brands in one place, so a parent can weigh a stroller against a carrier from another label in a single order. A price match is offered, which means a lower price found elsewhere on an identical item is worth raising before buying. Second-hand gear is also sold, so a parent on a tight budget can pick up a stroller, carrier or car seat without paying new-stock money. Returns run for 14 days from delivery, a window short enough to reward checking a car seat on arrival rather than weeks later.

How it compares on our data

The comparison picture across baby gear stores is mixed rather than dominant. On brands stocked, GoodBuy Gear ranks 5 of 10, so the assortment is broad without topping the table. On free delivery threshold the store sits 24 of 28, which is well down the order, and the same pattern holds on shipping fee at 21 of 23. Returns land between the two groups, at 17 of 30. The scores behind those ranks read 9.1 on offer and 8.2 on cost, for an overall 8.7. In other words, range and policy score well, while the delivery terms are what pull the wider picture down.

Plans and prices

Delivery is the line that decides the checkout total at GoodBuy Gear. Orders reaching $100 get free delivery, and smaller orders carry a $14.99 shipping charge on top of the item price. A single used stroller can sit under $100, which leaves the $14.99 charge attached to one piece of gear. Batching a car seat and a carrier into the same order pushes the basket over the threshold and the delivery charge drops away. That makes basket size the lever on total cost here, more than any single product price. Shoppers who would rather buy one item at a time should weigh the $14.99 charge against smaller-cart rivals.

The company behind it

GoodBuy Gear trades as Good Buy Gear, Inc. and is headquartered in the United States, which places the company in the same market as the parents it sells to. Support runs on email, chat and help centre: email carries the written questions, chat covers the quicker ones, and a help centre holds the answers parents look up most, from delivery options to how a return starts. A phone line does not appear among the listed channels, so a written answer is the route for anything complicated about an order, and a written thread also leaves a record of what was agreed if that order later comes back for a return.

How GoodBuy Gear compares

Where GoodBuy Gear is available

Available
United States

Countries from the brand (Source, checked September 30, 2026)

Frequently asked questions

How much is delivery at GoodBuy Gear?+

Delivery is free on orders reaching $100, and smaller orders are charged $14.99 on top of the item price. Both figures apply inside US only, so the delivery bill is the part of the checkout that basket size decides.

How long do I have to send something back?+

GoodBuy Gear runs a 14 day money-back period from delivery, which places the store at 17 of 30 on returns among the stores compared. The window is short enough to reward checking a car seat or stroller on arrival rather than weeks later.

Does GoodBuy Gear match lower prices elsewhere?+

A price match is offered, so a cheaper listing for the same item is worth raising with the store before you order. The match applies to the item price rather than to the $14.99 delivery charge, which makes it most useful on larger baskets rather than on a single low-priced piece.

Can I buy second-hand gear from GoodBuy Gear?+

Second-hand gear is sold, which opens a cheaper route to strollers, carriers and car seats for parents on a budget. The same second-hand terms sit alongside new stock, and the 14 day money-back period stands behind second-hand purchases as well, so a used buy is not a buy without recourse.

Where does GoodBuy Gear deliver?+

Delivery runs in US only, so store delivery does not extend to other markets. The company behind the store is Good Buy Gear, Inc., headquartered in the United States, and the $100 free delivery threshold and $14.99 shipping fee both sit inside that single market.

How many brands does GoodBuy Gear stock?+

The store lists 60 brands, close to the category median of 60. It ranks 5 of 10 on assortment, so the range is broad without topping the ranking, and a second-hand line adds a further way to browse the same categories.

How do I get help from GoodBuy Gear?+

Support runs on email, chat and help centre, so email, chat and a help centre are the listed ways to reach the store. A phone line does not appear among those channels, which matters when a car seat or stroller fault needs answering quickly and a written reply feels slow.

What alternatives have cheaper delivery?+

buybuy BABY sets free delivery at $49.99 and Albee Baby at $99, both below the $100 GoodBuy Gear asks. Mothercare lists SGD 60 in a different currency and market, so the bar is not directly comparable.

Sources

Compiled from 6 source pages, checked September 30, 2026. We did not open an account.

Not confirmed yet: Baby registry, Loyalty scheme.

GoodBuy Gear

US parents hunting second-hand baby gear with a price match and a short returns window.

8.7/10Visit

Your cookie choices

We use necessary cookies to make this site work. With your permission, analytics cookies help us understand usage and marketing cookies support advertising.

You can reject non-essential cookies and still use the site. Change your choices anytime in Cookie settings.

Cookie policy
Cookie settings